Choosing between the Common Admission Test (CAT) and the Xavier Aptitude Test (XAT) is a critical decision for MBA aspirants in India. Both exams are highly competitive and serve as gateways to prestigious business schools. However, each exam has its unique features, structure, and eligibility criteria, which makes it essential to understand their differences before deciding which one aligns better with your MBA goals.
1. Overview of CAT and XAT
- CAT is conducted by the Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs) and is the most popular MBA entrance exam in India. Apart from IIMs, more than 1,000 business schools across India accept CAT scores.
- XAT, conducted by XLRI Jamshedpur, is another widely accepted MBA entrance exam. In addition to XLRI, several other top B-schools, including SPJIMR, IMT Ghaziabad, and XIMB, accept XAT scores.
2. Exam Pattern
CAT consists of three sections:
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension (VARC)
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning (DILR)
- Quantitative Aptitude (QA)
The duration of the exam is 120 minutes, with 40 minutes allocated to each section. The test follows a multiple-choice and non-MCQ format, with penalties for incorrect answers in MCQs but none for non-MCQs.
XAT consists of four sections:
- Verbal and Logical Ability (VLA)
- Decision Making (DM)
- Quantitative Ability and Data Interpretation (QA & DI)
- General Knowledge (GK)
XAT is a longer exam, lasting for 180 minutes. While the first three sections contribute to the final percentile, the GK section is considered separately and used during the selection process.
Key Difference: The most significant difference is the Decision-Making section in XAT, which requires critical thinking and analysis, a section absent in CAT.
3. Difficulty Level
Both exams are known for their rigorous difficulty levels, but their challenges differ slightly.
- CAT: The Quantitative Aptitude section of CAT is generally considered tougher, requiring a strong foundation in mathematics. Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning are also complex, with convoluted questions that can be time-consuming.
- XAT: While XAT’s Quantitative section is also difficult, many consider its Decision-Making section to be one of the trickiest aspects of the exam. The Decision-Making questions test a candidate's judgment in business situations, something not seen in CAT.
Key Difference: CAT is more Quant-intensive, while XAT requires analytical decision-making skills.
4. Scoring and Negative Marking
CAT:
- For each correct answer, you score 3 points.
- Each wrong answer in MCQs results in a penalty of -1.
- No negative marking for non-MCQ questions.
XAT:
- For each correct answer, you score 1 point.
- There is a penalty of -0.25 for every wrong answer.
- XAT also has a unique penalty of -0.10 marks for unattempted questions beyond a certain limit (usually eight unattempted questions).
Key Difference: XAT penalizes not only wrong answers but also excessive unattempted questions, while CAT’s negative marking is confined to wrong answers in MCQs.
5. Acceptance and Eligibility
- CAT: Accepted by over 1,000 business schools, including the 20 IIMs and other top institutes such as FMS Delhi, SPJIMR, MDI Gurgaon, and more.
- XAT: Primarily accepted by XLRI Jamshedpur and around 150 other institutes, including top colleges like SPJIMR, XIMB, and IMT Ghaziabad.
Key Difference: CAT has a broader acceptance across B-schools in India, whereas XAT scores are limited to fewer institutes, but still some of the best.
6. Which Exam Should You Choose?
Take CAT if:
- Your dream schools include IIMs or other top institutes that exclusively accept CAT scores.
- You are confident in Quantitative Aptitude and Logical Reasoning.
- You prefer a shorter exam without additional sections like General Knowledge and Decision-Making.
Take XAT if:
- You are aiming for XLRI, XIMB, or institutes that prioritize XAT scores.
- You enjoy decision-making questions and possess strong logical and analytical skills.
- You are prepared for a longer, more comprehensive exam with sections like General Knowledge.
7. Exam Dates
- CAT: November 24, 2024
- XAT: January 5, 2025
Choosing between CAT and XAT ultimately depends on your strengths, preferences, and target schools. While CAT offers broader acceptability and focuses more on quantitative and reasoning skills, XAT tests a wider range of abilities, including decision-making and general knowledge. Carefully consider which exam aligns better with your MBA aspirations before making your choice.
Any question in your mind?
Connect to our counsellor: 8826807515
Share:
